Amazon has told users on its website and app that a New York City delivery bill could add up to $5 to each order if it passes. City Council Speaker Julie Menin called the claim false but left the door open to amending the bill.
Amazon is taking its case against a bill in New York City directly to customers. According to ABC7 New York, some users who opened Amazon's website and app on Wednesday saw pop-ups and banners saying prices and delivery fees could rise if the bill passes. One of the messages said orders could cost up to $5 more each.
The measure is the Delivery Protection Act. It would require Amazon to directly employ delivery workers who now work through third-party delivery companies, upending the outside-contractor delivery model Amazon has relied on. Mayor Zohran Mamdani publicly endorsed the bill in August, and labor groups, including the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, which is organizing Amazon delivery and warehouse workers, are backing it.
In the pop-up, Amazon said that if the bill passes, it might have to consider moving operations out of the city, which would make deliveries slower and more expensive for millions of New York City customers. A company spokesperson claimed the bill threatens the livelihoods of more than 40 small delivery companies Amazon works with in the city and the more than 5,000 New Yorkers they employ. ABC7's report, however, does not explain how the $5-per-order figure was calculated. The pop-up also urged users to contact their City Council members and oppose the bill.
Speaker Julie Menin criticized the messaging as false and misleading to consumers, saying that suggesting a $5 fee on every order deceives them. Mayor Mamdani also pushed back on social media, saying Amazon is a company worth trillions of dollars and that if a $5 charge were added to orders, it would be because of greed, not because of the Council's efforts to protect workers' rights and keep streets safe.
Some civil rights groups and the National Urban League also oppose the bill, because many of the affected delivery companies are Black-owned. Menin said she is aware of those concerns and will not pursue a path that costs people their jobs. She added that the bill could be amended to drop the provision banning third-party delivery companies and instead license and regulate warehouse operations. The bill is still a proposal, and discussions are continuing.

