Here are three good places in New York and New Jersey to buy a turkey and side dishes before Thanksgiving: Stew Leonard's, the family-run megastore; Zabar's, the Manhattan landmark that opened in 1934; and the Union Square Greenmarket, where farmers sell their own goods. We cover each one's signature items, addresses and shopping tips.

With Thanksgiving (Nov. 26) a week away, New York and New Jersey households are starting to plan their menus. Roast turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie all have to come from somewhere, so where you shop matters.

Here are three very different options: a big-box market that works as a family outing, a Manhattan grocery that has been around for more than 90 years, and a farmers market where growers sell directly.

① Stew Leonard's — Paramus, NJ, and Yonkers, NY

Stew Leonard's is a family-oriented supermarket chain with stores in Paramus, in New Jersey's Bergen County, and in Yonkers, New York. It was once listed in the Guinness World Records as the "world's largest dairy store." Animated character shows run throughout the store, which gives children a taste of the holiday mood while parents shop. The company also donates turkeys to local organizations every year through its Turkey Brigade, now in its 47th year.

Stew Leonard's ahead of Thanksgiving.
Stew Leonard's ahead of Thanksgiving. (Photo: NY&NJ)

This year's signature item is the Naked Turkey. These fresh turkeys are raised on vegetarian feed, without antibiotics or growth hormones, on farms in places such as Pennsylvania's Lehigh Valley. The company says they have more breast meat than conventional turkeys and 55% less fat.

There is also an Oven-Ready turkey, pre-seasoned with apples, oranges, onions, celery, rosemary and thyme, that only needs to go into the oven. A catering package that includes roast turkey, sage stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy and pie suits households with no time to cook. Pumpkin pies and apple cider doughnuts baked in the store are also popular this time of year.

② Zabar's — Upper West Side, Manhattan

Zabar's, which opened in 1934, is a grocery on the corner of 80th Street and Broadway on Manhattan's Upper West Side. New Yorkers line up here every holiday season for its classic city atmosphere and gourmet ingredients.

The founder of Zabar's.
The founder of Zabar's. (Photo: Zabar's website)

Zabar's offers a heat-and-serve Whole Roasted Free-Range Turkey and a Boneless Turkey Breast, so shoppers can choose according to the size of the table.

The selection of side dishes is especially wide. It includes chestnut stuffing, mushroom and caramelized onion stuffing, cornbread stuffing with dried fruit, candied yams, sweet potato purée and cranberry citrus compote.

For dessert, there is Zabar's signature chocolate babka, along with a harvest crumble pie made with apples, pears, cranberries and raisins, pecan pie and pumpkin cheesecake. A platter of Zabar's smoked salmon and cheese before the meal is a longtime New York tradition.

③ Union Square Greenmarket — Manhattan

The Union Square Greenmarket is New York City's largest farmers market, where farms from the Hudson Valley, Long Island, New Jersey and other nearby areas sell directly to shoppers. Every year before Thanksgiving, GrowNYC, the nonprofit that runs the market, publishes a "Turkey Guide" compiling each farm's turkey reservation details.

The key to shopping at the Greenmarket is the farm-raised, free-range turkey. Supplies from nearby farms such as DiPaola Turkey Farm are limited, so shoppers need to check the Turkey Guide, reserve with the farm ahead of time and pick up the bird at the market.

The Union Square Greenmarket ahead of Thanksgiving.
The Union Square Greenmarket ahead of Thanksgiving. (Photo: NY&NJ)

For side dishes, farms bring seasonal produce such as Brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes, kabocha squash, fresh cranberries and radicchio. Fresh-pressed apple cider and handmade pecan and apple pies are also on sale. During Thanksgiving week this year, the market will open on Tuesday (Nov. 24), a day it is normally closed, and will be closed on Friday (Nov. 27).

At a Glance

Three Thanksgiving Shopping Destinations
Stew Leonard's
Fresh Naked Turkey, Oven-Ready turkey, catering packages, pumpkin pie and apple cider doughnuts / Best for families with children and households that want a classic American spread
Zabar's
Whole roasted turkey, a wide range of stuffings, chocolate babka, smoked salmon / Best for Manhattan residents and households that want gourmet sides and desserts
Union Square Greenmarket
Farm-reserved turkeys, seasonal vegetables, apple cider / Best for households that want farm-direct ingredients

Addresses and Hours

Location
Stew Leonard's Paramus
700 Paramus Park, Paramus, NJ 07652 (Paramus Park mall)
Stew Leonard's Yonkers
1 Stew Leonard Dr, Yonkers, NY 10710
Stew Leonard's Online
stewleonards.com (online orders for turkey and catering)
Zabar's
2245 Broadway (at 80th Street), New York, NY 10024 / zabars.com
Union Square Greenmarket
North and west sides of Union Square Park (E 17th St & Union Square W) / Mon., Wed., Fri. and Sat., 8 a.m.–6 p.m. / grownyc.org
Greenmarket Thanksgiving Week Schedule
Special opening Tuesday, Nov. 24; closed Friday, Nov. 27; reopens Saturday, Nov. 28

Before You Shop

Frozen turkeys take time to thaw. A 15- to 20-pound bird needs three to four days in the refrigerator alone, so buy it at least four to five days before Thanksgiving and put it in the fridge.

Many stores close or close early on Thanksgiving Day (Nov. 26). To be safe, finish your shopping by Wednesday, the day before.

Fresh turkeys and catering packages can sell out early, so it's best to reserve ahead on each market's website.