Bluestone Lane, an Australian-style café, operates inside the Church of the Heavenly Rest at Fifth Avenue and 90th Street in Manhattan. Under 1920s Gothic stone arches, you can order a flat white and a smashed avocado toast, making it an easy stop on a walk along Museum Mile.

Three white umbrellas stand outside a gray stone church at the corner of Fifth Avenue and 90th Street, facing the Central Park Reservoir. Behind the Gothic arched entrance is a café, not a sanctuary: a Bluestone Lane shop, run by the Australian coffee chain inside the Church of the Heavenly Rest.

Umbrellas and outdoor seating outside the church's south entrance. The café is just inside this door.
Umbrellas and outdoor seating outside the church's south entrance. The café is just inside this door. (Photo: Aaron Lee)

A church on land bought from Mrs. Carnegie

According to the church, the Church of the Heavenly Rest is an Episcopal congregation founded in 1865, at the end of the Civil War, and its name honors soldiers who died in the war. It originally stood on Fifth Avenue in Midtown. When it moved uptown, it bought its current site from the wife of steel magnate Andrew Carnegie. The Carnegie mansion still stands one block north on 91st Street and now houses the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum.

The current building was designed by architect Hardie Phillip, with construction starting in 1926 and the church consecrated on Easter 1929. Its Gothic style with Art Deco touches is also called "Gothic Deco." It is a New York City landmark.

The Church of the Heavenly Rest, seen from across Fifth Avenue. The "Gothic Deco" building was consecrated in 1929.
The Church of the Heavenly Rest, seen from across Fifth Avenue. The "Gothic Deco" building was consecrated in 1929. (Photo: Aaron Lee)

A stone space beside the sanctuary becomes a café

Bluestone Lane opened here in July 2015. The New York news outlet DNAinfo reported at the time that it was the chain's sixth New York location, quoting the manager as calling it one of the most unusual cafés in the United States. The space was once a library and a bridal waiting room before weddings. The church designates the café a "community café" for neighbors and visitors and leaves its operation to Bluestone Lane. On weekends, it also serves coffee during worship hours.

The church's main entrance, framed by stone ornamentation.
The church's main entrance, framed by stone ornamentation. (Photo: Aaron Lee)

Inside, ribbed arches spring from the sandstone walls and meet at the center of the ceiling. Under the arch at the front are the bar counter and espresso machine, with rows of coffee bean bags on the shelves. A long wooden table, sky-blue chairs and white backless stools add a light touch of color to the stone interior. Behind the round pendant lights, a circular window is visible in the ceiling.

The bar counter and a long wooden table under the ribbed arches.
The bar counter and a long wooden table under the ribbed arches. (Photo: Aaron Lee)
Stone arches converge at the center of the ceiling, with a round window.
Stone arches converge at the center of the ceiling, with a round window. (Photo: Aaron Lee)
The stone-arched ceiling, the bar and a brunch spread. The video is stabilized. (Video: Aaron Lee)

Melbourne-style coffee and the "Avo Smash"

Bluestone Lane champions the Melbourne style, from the Australian city known for its coffee culture. The menu lists Australian-style flat whites and long blacks, a "magic" that is stronger than a flat white, and a piccolo. The signature avocado smash is multigrain toast topped with mashed avocado, sheep's milk feta, heirloom tomatoes and herbs. There is also a breakfast bowl with roasted kale and quinoa topped with a poached egg and avocado, as well as lemon ricotta pancakes. Breakfast is served all day.

The avocado smash: multigrain toast topped with feta, tomatoes and herbs.
The avocado smash: multigrain toast topped with feta, tomatoes and herbs. (Photo: Aaron Lee)
A bowl with avocado, poached egg, feta and grains.
A bowl with avocado, poached egg, feta and grains. (Photo: Aaron Lee)
Brunch served with a cappuccino.
Brunch served with a cappuccino. (Photo: Aaron Lee)

On Google Maps, the café has more than 2,600 reviews and a 4.5 rating out of 5. Users put the price at $20 to $30 per person. Reservations are taken through Resy, and pickup and delivery orders are available. On nice days, the outdoor seats under the umbrellas on the Fifth Avenue side fill up first.

Outdoor seating on the Fifth Avenue side, seen through the glass door.
Outdoor seating on the Fifth Avenue side, seen through the glass door. (Photo: Aaron Lee)

A stop on a Museum Mile walk

The stretch of Fifth Avenue from 82nd to 105th Street, where the café is located, is known as Museum Mile for its concentration of museums. The Guggenheim Museum is one or two blocks south, between 88th and 89th Streets, and the Cooper Hewitt design museum is one block north. The Metropolitan Museum of Art is also within walking distance. Across the street is the Central Park Reservoir path. The nearest subway is the 4, 5 and 6 at 86th Street on Lexington Avenue, about a 10-minute walk away.

Bluestone Lane, Church of the Heavenly Rest Café
Address
1085 Fifth Ave, New York, NY 10128 (Fifth Avenue and 90th Street)
Hours
Until 6 p.m. (per Google Maps; opening time varies by day)
Price range
$20 to $30 per person (per Google Maps users)
Signature items
Flat white, avocado smash, breakfast bowl, lemon ricotta pancakes
Reservations
Resy / pickup and delivery orders available
Nearby
Guggenheim Museum, Cooper Hewitt design museum, Central Park Reservoir

Menus and hours are available on the Bluestone Lane website (bluestonelane.com) and on Google Maps.