A bill introduced in the New York City Council on Thursday, Feb. 19, would ban cooking live crustaceans by boiling them alive. A first violation would bring a warning, and each violation after that would carry a $100 fine per animal. Restaurant industry figures have pushed back, and a vote is not expected anytime soon.
A bill introduced in the New York City Council on Thursday would ban boiling live crustaceans such as lobsters and crabs alive. According to the New York Post, a first violation would draw only a warning, and each violation after that would carry a $100 fine for every crustacean boiled alive. The bill defines the covered animals as crustaceans "including, but not limited to, lobsters and crabs."
The bill was introduced by Council Members Oswald Feliz, who represents a district in the Bronx, and Harvey Epstein, who represents a Manhattan district. Restaurants could keep selling lobster, but they would have to set up a procedure for killing the animals before cooking. Switzerland, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, Austria, Norway and parts of Australia already have similar bans. These countries generally recommend stunning the animal with an electric shock or by freezing, then killing it by severing the nervous system with a knife.
Animal welfare groups argue that crustaceans feel pain in boiling water, and some studies have found pain responses similar to those of mammals. Other experts counter that crustaceans have a simple nervous system, like insects, and do not feel pain. Feliz told the Post that boiling animals alive is animal cruelty, and he stressed that the bill would not take lobster off menus or stop people from eating it.
The restaurant industry is pushing back. Angelo Vivolo, a retired figure in the New York Italian restaurant business, called the rule absurd. Zach Erdem, a well-known chef in the Hamptons, said restaurants already struggle with rent, food costs, labor and taxes, and that the city is now adding more regulation. He said he might abandon his plans to open a restaurant in Manhattan.
A separate bill pending before the Council would ban giving away goldfish as prizes anywhere in the city. The Post reported that both bills are likely to take a while to reach a vote. The city's 2019 ordinance banning the sale of foie gras has been tied up in court appeals ever since.

